Comments on: Monsoon Song Showdown: Do Bigha Zameen (1953) vs. Lagaan (2001)

By: dunkdaft

dunkdaft — Sun, 04 Jul 2010 07:03:36 +0000

Thanks for putting up link to my blogpost of 105 songs. wondering I haven’t commented here before

By: KUSUM

KUSUM — Thu, 17 Jun 2010 20:31:22 +0000

I agree, both songs are similar and we used to love the old song when it used to rain in Jaipur, that song makes me feel like I am standing outside just after the rain stops.

Kusum

By: Sumana

Sumana — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 14:22:08 +0000

To answer your question about Gowarikar acknowledging DBZ: I do not know if the acknowledgement shows up in the film’s credits, but I was attending a seminar about Bimal Roy a few months ago, and one of the speakers (I think it was film critic Maithili Rao) mentioned that Gowarikar has mentioned in interviews how much he admires Bimal Roy’s work and has also talked about how he was inspired by the monsoon song in DBZ while making Lagaan. So your noticing the similarity was spot-on. There’s a new film about Bimal Roy made by his son Joy Bimal Roy and Ashutosh Gowarikar is interviewed in that as well. I do recommend watching the documentary if you like Roy’s films – not a particularly objective protrait, nevertheless, interesting to watch.

By: my_dog_jagat

my_dog_jagat — Sat, 12 Jun 2010 22:47:05 +0000

Amardeep thanks for this. They are both great songs. You indirectly asked for a comparison by posting the two clips so here goes: The Lagaan song is stronger both in the photography and in capturing the joyous anticipation of sawan and so while I am firmly in the "old is gold" camp I'll have to go with the Lagaan song.

Darwin: I've been told that the best way to recognize a raga is to learn a ditty in one and then use it as a matching template. Nice way to impress dates.

By: Chakaas

Chakaas — Sat, 12 Jun 2010 05:39:21 +0000

Oh, you old farts…

By: Sameer

Sameer — Sat, 12 Jun 2010 00:06:22 +0000

Do Bigha Zameen if I had to choose between the two, but I like both songs. Kudos to both of them!

By: jyotsana

jyotsana — Fri, 11 Jun 2010 23:45:31 +0000

Before DBZ there was Chetan Anand's Neecha Nagar inspired (scripted?) by Khwaja Ahmed Abbas (based on a short story by Hayatullah Ansari) in turn based on a Gorky work. It is the first and only Indian film to win the top prize at Cannes, which it did in 1946

By: Darwin

Darwin — Fri, 11 Jun 2010 22:01:50 +0000

I am not 100% sure, but the reason both songs sound the same is that they are both based on the raga Megh Malhar. Here is a rendition of said raga by Ustads Salamat and Nazakat Ali Khan.

Do Bigha Zameen was a seminal piece of work in more ways than one. In my opinion, it reinforced a sense of social equality among the bhadralok, and infused a communist zeal in West bengal for decades to come. The end of the movie shows Shambhu's (Balraj Sahni's character) land being used to build a factory. Witness the opposition to the Tata Nano plan in Singur a couple of years ago.

Also, if you notice, the 'villains' of movies made in the two decades following Independence were often landgrabbing zamindars, cheating money-lenders (Mother India) and nefarious industrialists (Shree 420), reflecting the post-independence malaise that afflicted a lot of people in the hinterland. I have a theory that Hindi movie villains almost always represent prevalent ills in Indian society in general.

Stylistically, DBZ was also the trendsetter for parallel cinema (arthouse) for decades to come.

By: Yo Dad

Yo Dad — Fri, 11 Jun 2010 19:03:23 +0000

Amardeep: Thanks for little trip back in time. I remember very well the movie “Do Bhigha Zamin”. This movie was in my “Prime Time” growing up in India. Balraj Sahani was superb and so were the evergreen songs. Laggan was OK, but nothing compared to DBZ. Thanks.

By: Melissa

Melissa — Fri, 11 Jun 2010 18:35:29 +0000

Thanks for sharing this Amardeep; I haven’t seen Do Bigha Zameen but if the rest of the movie is as enchanting as Hariyala Sawan Dhol Bjata Aya then I’ll definitely be checking it out. The imagery and personality of the songs are very similar, no doubt Lagaan took some artistic inspiration from the earlier number.