Comments on: Forget Will Smith, Time For Karva Chauth http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/ All that flavorful brownness in one savory packet Sat, 30 Nov 2013 11:11:28 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Sarah http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194204 Sarah Tue, 19 Feb 2008 10:34:39 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194204 <p>UncleDude you are so regressive to be offended by four letter words.</p> UncleDude you are so regressive to be offended by four letter words.

]]>
By: UncleDude http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194119 UncleDude Mon, 18 Feb 2008 22:10:09 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194119 <p>I am a little surprised about the frequent use of four-letter words both in English and Indian languages in a forum like <b>SM</b>. I thougt such use is not done in mixed company and in a public forum. A lot of times a point can be made without use of such words. I see important and serious issues discussed here by youngsters in a meaningful way. I learn a lot on <b>SM</b> about current events pertaining to desi Americans. Please understand I am not suggesting complete ban of any such words either.</p> I am a little surprised about the frequent use of four-letter words both in English and Indian languages in a forum like SM. I thougt such use is not done in mixed company and in a public forum. A lot of times a point can be made without use of such words. I see important and serious issues discussed here by youngsters in a meaningful way. I learn a lot on SM about current events pertaining to desi Americans. Please understand I am not suggesting complete ban of any such words either.

]]>
By: Wanted http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194089 Wanted Mon, 18 Feb 2008 19:53:04 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194089 <p>OK. But let me just write what it was coz I think it's a terrific play on words;</p> <p>WANTED: A Karva Choot for a Karva Chod!</p> <p>Hindi bhasha wallas will laff....</p> <p>PS: what's wrong with long handles? (no pun intended)</p> OK. But let me just write what it was coz I think it’s a terrific play on words;

WANTED: A Karva Choot for a Karva Chod!

Hindi bhasha wallas will laff….

PS: what’s wrong with long handles? (no pun intended)

]]>
By: SM Intern http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194087 SM Intern Mon, 18 Feb 2008 19:45:40 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194087 <p>"Wanted..."</p> <p>Please don't use a long handle name. Keep it short. Thanks.</p> “Wanted…”

Please don’t use a long handle name. Keep it short. Thanks.

]]>
By: Wanted http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194086 Wanted Mon, 18 Feb 2008 19:33:40 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194086 <blockquote>Given the meaning of marriage itself is going to change (I dont' have faith that the <b>divorce</b> rate in India won't grow in next 50-100 years), what good is Karva Chauth then (it would be funny to know <b>which husband </b>a woman is keeping fast for)?</blockquote> <p>Violet, once a person is divorced, they no longer have a spouse. If after divorcing they then remarry, they then have ONLY ONE spouse, that is the person they are currently married to.</p> <p>Ex-husbands are not husbands.</p> <p>When I was living in a small town in India the people there also assumed that somehow an ex-spouse was still a spouse and would joke and make fun of men or women who had 2 or 3 wives, when in reality, they had one wife or husband and maybe one or two EX-spouses. They did not get the idea of an ex-wife or ex-husband.</p> <p>In fact, when my friend's ex husband came to India to visit his son, she could not convince her landlord to give the man his own room. He insisted, "he is your husband, he will stay with you".</p> <p>Funny, the guy was never really her husband to begin with as they never got legally married anywhere. Nevertheless, she kept trying to explain to her landlord the concept of divorce and "ex", but he would have none of it. The father of her child ended up staying with her, against her wishes.</p> <p>Disclaimer; I'm aware that in Mumbai and a few other places in India where divorce may be more common, there are indeed people who DO understand these concepts.</p> Given the meaning of marriage itself is going to change (I dont’ have faith that the divorce rate in India won’t grow in next 50-100 years), what good is Karva Chauth then (it would be funny to know which husband a woman is keeping fast for)?

Violet, once a person is divorced, they no longer have a spouse. If after divorcing they then remarry, they then have ONLY ONE spouse, that is the person they are currently married to.

Ex-husbands are not husbands.

When I was living in a small town in India the people there also assumed that somehow an ex-spouse was still a spouse and would joke and make fun of men or women who had 2 or 3 wives, when in reality, they had one wife or husband and maybe one or two EX-spouses. They did not get the idea of an ex-wife or ex-husband.

In fact, when my friend’s ex husband came to India to visit his son, she could not convince her landlord to give the man his own room. He insisted, “he is your husband, he will stay with you”.

Funny, the guy was never really her husband to begin with as they never got legally married anywhere. Nevertheless, she kept trying to explain to her landlord the concept of divorce and “ex”, but he would have none of it. The father of her child ended up staying with her, against her wishes.

Disclaimer; I’m aware that in Mumbai and a few other places in India where divorce may be more common, there are indeed people who DO understand these concepts.

]]>
By: Wanted http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194083 Wanted Mon, 18 Feb 2008 19:21:28 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194083 <p>And Karva Chauth was in November. Why is it being blogged about now as if it's happening now?</p> And Karva Chauth was in November. Why is it being blogged about now as if it’s happening now?

]]>
By: Wanted http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194081 Wanted Mon, 18 Feb 2008 19:15:32 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194081 <p>LOL. Sorry for the vulgarities, thought it was aptly funny. And besides, bad words don't sound so bad in foriegn languages, now do they?</p> <p>Karva Chauth, where to begin. Been present in India for many a season.</p> <p>In the cities there's a standard joke that this is the one day you will find cinemas packed with ladies only, because without eating, what else do they have to do at home? (A little insight into the class system there).</p> <p>As a public figure it's good that at least Ash's hubby is stating he will fast also. This might influence some of their male fans to do the same act of solidarity with their wives. I wonder how the mother-in-laws feel about that though? Often when a young hubby tries to cook or clean around the house to help his wife, his mother won't allow her "prince" to do any such thing. Can't imagine too many Indian saas's celebrating their sons fasting in solidarity with their bahu's. The less time spent with her the better, seems to be the motto.</p> <p>The funny thing about this holiday is that at the end of the day the wife is supposed to go to the roof top of her home and hold a plate up to the sky and capture the moon's reflection in it. Then she is supposed to feed her husband a bite of food (which she cooked while fasting), and after his bite, she then takes a bite and breaks her fast.</p> <p>She was fasting all day and she has to cook? She was fasting all day and HE gets the first bite?</p> <p>Once on that day I asked one man who's wife was fasting for HIS longevity what he was doing for her, he said, "my whole life is for her, I don't need to fast".</p> <p>Whatevs.</p> LOL. Sorry for the vulgarities, thought it was aptly funny. And besides, bad words don’t sound so bad in foriegn languages, now do they?

Karva Chauth, where to begin. Been present in India for many a season.

In the cities there’s a standard joke that this is the one day you will find cinemas packed with ladies only, because without eating, what else do they have to do at home? (A little insight into the class system there).

As a public figure it’s good that at least Ash’s hubby is stating he will fast also. This might influence some of their male fans to do the same act of solidarity with their wives. I wonder how the mother-in-laws feel about that though? Often when a young hubby tries to cook or clean around the house to help his wife, his mother won’t allow her “prince” to do any such thing. Can’t imagine too many Indian saas’s celebrating their sons fasting in solidarity with their bahu’s. The less time spent with her the better, seems to be the motto.

The funny thing about this holiday is that at the end of the day the wife is supposed to go to the roof top of her home and hold a plate up to the sky and capture the moon’s reflection in it. Then she is supposed to feed her husband a bite of food (which she cooked while fasting), and after his bite, she then takes a bite and breaks her fast.

She was fasting all day and she has to cook? She was fasting all day and HE gets the first bite?

Once on that day I asked one man who’s wife was fasting for HIS longevity what he was doing for her, he said, “my whole life is for her, I don’t need to fast”.

Whatevs.

]]>
By: Sarah http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194037 Sarah Mon, 18 Feb 2008 11:09:55 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194037 <p>Carol - You go girl.. you have made great posts.. and gosh people here just seem like the ones who love the sound of their own voice..</p> <p>Gosh internet really is full of people who always have all these opinions but only a few actually have knowledge in what they are talking about</p> <p>Aish never married a tree, it was just imagination of some B grade magazine and everyone ran along with it because it sounds funny..and all these pseudo intelligent desis, they found another excuse to show off how they are so "modern".. and bash a celebrity</p> Carol – You go girl.. you have made great posts.. and gosh people here just seem like the ones who love the sound of their own voice..

Gosh internet really is full of people who always have all these opinions but only a few actually have knowledge in what they are talking about

Aish never married a tree, it was just imagination of some B grade magazine and everyone ran along with it because it sounds funny..and all these pseudo intelligent desis, they found another excuse to show off how they are so “modern”.. and bash a celebrity

]]>
By: Kush Tandon http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194025 Kush Tandon Mon, 18 Feb 2008 06:43:26 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194025 <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasting">I stand corrected every religion <b>except Sikhism</b> promotes fasting, and in Islam (where it is for a month during the month of Ramadan/ Ramzan), Judaism, Catholicism (both mainstream and versions like Opus Dei), Evangelical Protestantism (fastest growing religion, and increasingly popular activity), it forms an important religious activity.</a></p> I stand corrected every religion except Sikhism promotes fasting, and in Islam (where it is for a month during the month of Ramadan/ Ramzan), Judaism, Catholicism (both mainstream and versions like Opus Dei), Evangelical Protestantism (fastest growing religion, and increasingly popular activity), it forms an important religious activity.

]]>
By: Kush Tandon http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2008/02/12/forget_will_smi/comment-page-5/#comment-194024 Kush Tandon Mon, 18 Feb 2008 06:07:43 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=5020#comment-194024 <p><i>Now, I don't know how healthy or widespread the practice of fasting is, but I guess it is a minor part of the culture today.</i></p> <p>Every <b><a href="http://www.beliefnet.com/features/fasting_chart.html">major religion</a></b> has fasting as one of their components - <a href="http://www.beliefnet.com/features/fasting_chart.html">Here is a list, and their significance</a>.</p> Now, I don’t know how healthy or widespread the practice of fasting is, but I guess it is a minor part of the culture today.

Every major religion has fasting as one of their components – Here is a list, and their significance.

]]>