Comments on: A Documentary About Sanjay Dutt on YouTube http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/ All that flavorful brownness in one savory packet Sat, 30 Nov 2013 11:11:28 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: sanik shiva http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-3/#comment-157114 sanik shiva Wed, 08 Aug 2007 14:50:40 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-157114 <p>Hey guys,</p> <p>this is strange.. I cannot find the navakal newspaper in town, but i saw the website has come up since 2 days at</p> <p>http://www.navakal.com</p> <p>Shiv sena</p> Hey guys,

this is strange.. I cannot find the navakal newspaper in town, but i saw the website has come up since 2 days at

http://www.navakal.com

Shiv sena

]]>
By: Rahul http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-3/#comment-156284 Rahul Sun, 05 Aug 2007 22:24:08 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156284 <blockquote>our respective parents used to economize by combining our birthday parties into one... So we dedicated our 35th wedding anniversary cake to her.</blockquote> <p>Glad it was so much fun! You know what they say. The family that saves together stays together.</p> <blockquote>Not in the same class as Khushwant Singh, though.</blockquote> <p>Is Khushwant Singh good? I never liked the short stories of his that I read growing up? Maybe because I felt the language was very plain and insipid, I don't know. I haven't read <i>Train to Pakistan</i> though. What do you recommend as good Khushwant Singh works to read?</p> <blockquote>After the last Munnabhai movie, he is a folk hero, and starring in movies as a person dutifully paying for his crime will really resonate with the Indian public.</blockquote> <p>But only under threat of life without parole if the third Munnabhai sucks and they destroy the franchise. The <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUbJaOpfpfo">trailer</a> for the third one looked quite good.</p> our respective parents used to economize by combining our birthday parties into one… So we dedicated our 35th wedding anniversary cake to her.

Glad it was so much fun! You know what they say. The family that saves together stays together.

Not in the same class as Khushwant Singh, though.

Is Khushwant Singh good? I never liked the short stories of his that I read growing up? Maybe because I felt the language was very plain and insipid, I don’t know. I haven’t read Train to Pakistan though. What do you recommend as good Khushwant Singh works to read?

After the last Munnabhai movie, he is a folk hero, and starring in movies as a person dutifully paying for his crime will really resonate with the Indian public.

But only under threat of life without parole if the third Munnabhai sucks and they destroy the franchise. The trailer for the third one looked quite good.

]]>
By: ak http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156266 ak Sun, 05 Aug 2007 19:05:11 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156266 <blockquote>Woh Chikne ki maar di hain ekdam first-class".</blockquote> <p>i browsed through those trancripts (thanks for the link) - i think 'first-class' is my new favourite word :)</p> <blockquote>Not in the same class as Khushwant Singh, though.</blockquote> <p>i just picked up <i>death at my doorstep</i> by KS - it's a collection of obituaries of people personally known to him as well as public figures. i think he ends it with one on himself.</p> <blockquote>Why not let him rake in millions acting in the 6 or 8 movies he has signed up for and donate the proceeds to a worthwhile charity</blockquote> <p>? not a bad one. but i think a lot of people would prob. object on the fact that it would be somewhat equivalent to bail - and the notion that this sentence is hitting him where it hurts - he values his freedom more than his money (said amount being somewhat minimal to his already accumulated wealth).</p> Woh Chikne ki maar di hain ekdam first-class”.

i browsed through those trancripts (thanks for the link) – i think ‘first-class’ is my new favourite word :)

Not in the same class as Khushwant Singh, though.

i just picked up death at my doorstep by KS – it’s a collection of obituaries of people personally known to him as well as public figures. i think he ends it with one on himself.

Why not let him rake in millions acting in the 6 or 8 movies he has signed up for and donate the proceeds to a worthwhile charity

? not a bad one. but i think a lot of people would prob. object on the fact that it would be somewhat equivalent to bail – and the notion that this sentence is hitting him where it hurts – he values his freedom more than his money (said amount being somewhat minimal to his already accumulated wealth).

]]>
By: Floridian http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156258 Floridian Sun, 05 Aug 2007 16:37:02 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156258 <p>22 · Rahul on August 1, 2007 08:51 AM · Direct link Yay, Floridian is baaaaaaaaack!</p> <p>The party was great. Listen to this. One of my cousins in Delhi has the same birthday as mine. Back in the sixties, when both of us were young teens, our respective parents used to economize by combining our birthday parties into one. Turns out that my cousin's daughter has the same birthday as our wedding anniversary. So we dedicated our 35th wedding anniversary cake to her. After thirty-some years, my cousin and I were celebrating something together again. Now, how cool is that!</p> <p>Eliot was good reading. I am picking up on Dalrymple now. Not in the same class as Khushwant Singh, though.</p> <p>Not to go completely AWOL on the thread, here is a thought on Sanju, as the Page 3 glitterati calls him here in Delhi. Why not let him rake in millions acting in the 6 or 8 movies he has signed up for and donate the proceeds to a worthwhile charity? I can guaranee you each one of his movies will be a hit. Even though the majority of public opinion is in favor of the sentence, that does not take anything away from the huge affection people feel for him. After the last Munnabhai movie, he is a folk hero, and starring in movies as a person dutifully paying for his crime will really resonate with the Indian public.</p> 22 · Rahul on August 1, 2007 08:51 AM · Direct link Yay, Floridian is baaaaaaaaack!

The party was great. Listen to this. One of my cousins in Delhi has the same birthday as mine. Back in the sixties, when both of us were young teens, our respective parents used to economize by combining our birthday parties into one. Turns out that my cousin’s daughter has the same birthday as our wedding anniversary. So we dedicated our 35th wedding anniversary cake to her. After thirty-some years, my cousin and I were celebrating something together again. Now, how cool is that!

Eliot was good reading. I am picking up on Dalrymple now. Not in the same class as Khushwant Singh, though.

Not to go completely AWOL on the thread, here is a thought on Sanju, as the Page 3 glitterati calls him here in Delhi. Why not let him rake in millions acting in the 6 or 8 movies he has signed up for and donate the proceeds to a worthwhile charity? I can guaranee you each one of his movies will be a hit. Even though the majority of public opinion is in favor of the sentence, that does not take anything away from the huge affection people feel for him. After the last Munnabhai movie, he is a folk hero, and starring in movies as a person dutifully paying for his crime will really resonate with the Indian public.

]]>
By: Shodan http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156117 Shodan Fri, 03 Aug 2007 18:35:18 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156117 <p>Moornam, I too have read those transcripts. I don't remember Dutt wanting to kill anyone. There was this bit where Shakeel said, "You have outclassed Rhitik Roshan in Mission Kashmir". In taporese "Woh Chikne ki maar di hain ekdam first-class". <a href="http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/jul2002/msg01622.html">(link)</a></p> <p>Lost in translation?</p> Moornam, I too have read those transcripts. I don’t remember Dutt wanting to kill anyone. There was this bit where Shakeel said, “You have outclassed Rhitik Roshan in Mission Kashmir”. In taporese “Woh Chikne ki maar di hain ekdam first-class”. (link)

Lost in translation?

]]>
By: Cliff http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156112 Cliff Fri, 03 Aug 2007 17:43:40 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156112 <p>Sanjay Dutt is guilty by association with the Mumbai Underworld. Also arrogant,stupid and naive that he is above the law. Enough with the Sanju baba crap....he is almost 50 years old. Next are the killers of Jessica Lal, the drunk ones who mowed down poor urchins and police men in Mumbai and Delhi.</p> <p>If you want to drill civic sense into people, they have to realize that law applies to all.</p> Sanjay Dutt is guilty by association with the Mumbai Underworld. Also arrogant,stupid and naive that he is above the law. Enough with the Sanju baba crap….he is almost 50 years old. Next are the killers of Jessica Lal, the drunk ones who mowed down poor urchins and police men in Mumbai and Delhi.

If you want to drill civic sense into people, they have to realize that law applies to all.

]]>
By: ak http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156110 ak Fri, 03 Aug 2007 17:31:37 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156110 <p>moornam - i had no idea. perhaps the TADA court felt there wasn't enough to support a charge of terrorism, but the sentencing was some implicit way of reflecting some element of terrorist activity? on the other hand, even though i sort of feel bad he has to go back to jail (or maybe not, now knowing more information), i don't know how sentencing guidelines work in india - 6 years for holding a weapon like an AK-56 arguably seems on the lighter side, and it could be at the lower end of the sentencing range for this crime. either way, he did commit at least this one crime, and if this is within the permissive sentencing, it cannot be argued that it was unjust.</p> moornam – i had no idea. perhaps the TADA court felt there wasn’t enough to support a charge of terrorism, but the sentencing was some implicit way of reflecting some element of terrorist activity? on the other hand, even though i sort of feel bad he has to go back to jail (or maybe not, now knowing more information), i don’t know how sentencing guidelines work in india – 6 years for holding a weapon like an AK-56 arguably seems on the lighter side, and it could be at the lower end of the sentencing range for this crime. either way, he did commit at least this one crime, and if this is within the permissive sentencing, it cannot be argued that it was unjust.

]]>
By: MoorNam http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156105 MoorNam Fri, 03 Aug 2007 16:44:49 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156105 <p>I too had sympathies for Sanjay till a point in time. I was ready to accept arguments that he may be an innocent victim in all this. However, my perception changed in 2000-2001 when recorded conversations were made public wherein he was speaking with Chota Shakeel to bump of Hritik Roshan because be was becoming too famous (<i>Chikne to maarna hai</i>...). That was it - since then I have no mercy for him and I'm ready to believe the worst about him.</p> <p>Six years is too less.</p> <p>M. Nam</p> I too had sympathies for Sanjay till a point in time. I was ready to accept arguments that he may be an innocent victim in all this. However, my perception changed in 2000-2001 when recorded conversations were made public wherein he was speaking with Chota Shakeel to bump of Hritik Roshan because be was becoming too famous (Chikne to maarna hai…). That was it – since then I have no mercy for him and I’m ready to believe the worst about him.

Six years is too less.

M. Nam

]]>
By: NEERAJ http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156088 NEERAJ Fri, 03 Aug 2007 15:32:17 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156088 <p>Read it <a href="http://neerajdiwan.wordpress.com/2007/08/01/sanjaydutt/"></p> <p>I have written on SANJAY DUTT.. <a href="http://neerajdiwan.wordpress.com/2007/08/01/sanjaydutt/"> </a></a></p> Read it

I have written on SANJAY DUTT..

]]>
By: Samir http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2007/07/31/a_documentary_a/comment-page-2/#comment-156050 Samir Fri, 03 Aug 2007 06:25:05 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=4617#comment-156050 <p>why haven't they yet jailed Salman Khan for drunk driving and vehicular homicide?</p> <p>That trial is still running.</p> why haven’t they yet jailed Salman Khan for drunk driving and vehicular homicide?

That trial is still running.

]]>