Comments on: I smell a revolting odour in what you speak http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/ All that flavorful brownness in one savory packet Sat, 30 Nov 2013 11:11:28 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Floridian http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-75138 Floridian Wed, 26 Jul 2006 01:50:30 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-75138 <p>Matrimonial columns seem to insist that brides be "fair." My daughter, only 8 at the time she happened to read India Abroad's matrimonial, wanted to know if there were a lot of unfair people among Indians - hence the need for "fair" brides.</p> Matrimonial columns seem to insist that brides be “fair.” My daughter, only 8 at the time she happened to read India Abroad’s matrimonial, wanted to know if there were a lot of unfair people among Indians – hence the need for “fair” brides.

]]>
By: Dave Adair http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74762 Dave Adair Sun, 23 Jul 2006 19:10:10 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74762 <p>Hello all. I'm Jon Carroll's "friend of a friend" that took the quotes from the True Crimes magazine. You can see my original post on my blog here: http://www.daveadair.com/blog/2006/07/true-crimes-whom-are-you-calling-as.html</p> <p>All of the sentences were taken directly from the magazine, but as I said on my blog, I searched long and hard to find the worst (and funniest) examples of what I call "mangled English." I've always loved terrible English, and as an avid traveler I get to see a lot of it. But these examples weren't at all representative of the magazine - only the worst/best examples. I'm sure I would find it funny in any other language that I speak fluently - but not surprisingly, I only speak English! And I would never criticize bad English. I just think it's funny.</p> <p>If anyone is curious, I bought that magazine in Kalimpong, near Darjeeling. And I'm writing now from Srinagar, where I've just arrived two days ago.</p> <p>Dave</p> Hello all. I’m Jon Carroll’s “friend of a friend” that took the quotes from the True Crimes magazine. You can see my original post on my blog here: http://www.daveadair.com/blog/2006/07/true-crimes-whom-are-you-calling-as.html

All of the sentences were taken directly from the magazine, but as I said on my blog, I searched long and hard to find the worst (and funniest) examples of what I call “mangled English.” I’ve always loved terrible English, and as an avid traveler I get to see a lot of it. But these examples weren’t at all representative of the magazine – only the worst/best examples. I’m sure I would find it funny in any other language that I speak fluently – but not surprisingly, I only speak English! And I would never criticize bad English. I just think it’s funny.

If anyone is curious, I bought that magazine in Kalimpong, near Darjeeling. And I’m writing now from Srinagar, where I’ve just arrived two days ago.

Dave

]]>
By: Satish http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74760 Satish Sun, 23 Jul 2006 18:20:30 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74760 <p>I am loving it.</p> <p><b>Anyways, do you know of the cow?</b></p> <p>The cow is a successful animal. Also he is quadrupud, and because he is female, he give milk,but will do so when he is got child.He is same like God,sacred to Hindus and useful to man.But he has got four legs together. Two are forward and two are afterwards.</p> <p>His whole body can be utilised for use. More so the milk. What can it do? Various ghee, butter,cream, curd, why and the condensed milk and so forth. Also he is useful to cobbler, watermans and mankind generally.</p> <p>His motion is slow only because he is of asitudinious species. Also his other motion is much useful to trees, plants as well as making flat cakes in hand and drying in the sun. Cow is the only animal that extricates his feeding after eating. Then afterwards she chew with his teeth whom are situated in the inside of the mouth. He is incessantly in the meadows in the grass.</p> <p>His only attacking and defending organ is the horn, specially so when he is got child. This is done by knowing his head whereby he causes the weapons to be paralleled to the ground of the earth and instantly proceed with great velocity forwards.</p> <p>He has got tails also, but not like similar animals. It has hairs on the other end of the other side. This is done to frighten away the flies which alight on his cohoa body whereupon he gives hit with it.</p> <p>The palms of his feet are soft unto the touch. So the grasses head is not crushed. At night time have poses by looking down on the ground and he shouts his eyes like his relatives, the horse does not do so.</p> <p>This is the cow.</p> I am loving it.

Anyways, do you know of the cow?

The cow is a successful animal. Also he is quadrupud, and because he is female, he give milk,but will do so when he is got child.He is same like God,sacred to Hindus and useful to man.But he has got four legs together. Two are forward and two are afterwards.

His whole body can be utilised for use. More so the milk. What can it do? Various ghee, butter,cream, curd, why and the condensed milk and so forth. Also he is useful to cobbler, watermans and mankind generally.

His motion is slow only because he is of asitudinious species. Also his other motion is much useful to trees, plants as well as making flat cakes in hand and drying in the sun. Cow is the only animal that extricates his feeding after eating. Then afterwards she chew with his teeth whom are situated in the inside of the mouth. He is incessantly in the meadows in the grass.

His only attacking and defending organ is the horn, specially so when he is got child. This is done by knowing his head whereby he causes the weapons to be paralleled to the ground of the earth and instantly proceed with great velocity forwards.

He has got tails also, but not like similar animals. It has hairs on the other end of the other side. This is done to frighten away the flies which alight on his cohoa body whereupon he gives hit with it.

The palms of his feet are soft unto the touch. So the grasses head is not crushed. At night time have poses by looking down on the ground and he shouts his eyes like his relatives, the horse does not do so.

This is the cow.

]]>
By: brown_fob http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74728 brown_fob Sun, 23 Jul 2006 01:39:36 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74728 <p>To sum up this discussion, an Indian might say ..."we are like that only". On the other hand, an American might say "Indians don't know no good English".</p> To sum up this discussion, an Indian might say …”we are like that only”. On the other hand, an American might say “Indians don’t know no good English”.

]]>
By: DesiDudeInGotham (formerly of Austin) http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74693 DesiDudeInGotham (formerly of Austin) Sat, 22 Jul 2006 16:18:20 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74693 <blockquote>You wrote your sickness letters from scratch? I'm very impressed :) </blockquote> <p>Ofcourse not! Why would you think I forged letters? From scratch that too :)</p> You wrote your sickness letters from scratch? I’m very impressed :)

Ofcourse not! Why would you think I forged letters? From scratch that too :)

]]>
By: milli http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74683 milli Sat, 22 Jul 2006 13:25:15 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74683 <p>You are all having it going on!</p> <p>Anyway. I am in India right now, and my 8 year old cousin speaks English WAY better than I speak our mother tongue. Granted, it's with an accent and occasionally funny expressions; but she speaks quickly, accurately, and can convey humor and sarcasm in English. That's impressive to me. What the hell do I care if it's with an accent? I've rarely met an Amreekan who speaks a foreign language with the same mastery that many, many immigrants have of English.</p> You are all having it going on!

Anyway. I am in India right now, and my 8 year old cousin speaks English WAY better than I speak our mother tongue. Granted, it’s with an accent and occasionally funny expressions; but she speaks quickly, accurately, and can convey humor and sarcasm in English. That’s impressive to me. What the hell do I care if it’s with an accent? I’ve rarely met an Amreekan who speaks a foreign language with the same mastery that many, many immigrants have of English.

]]>
By: sleepy http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74665 sleepy Sat, 22 Jul 2006 06:14:29 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74665 <p>"Dude... I learnt writing like this"</p> <p>You wrote your sickness letters from scratch? I'm very impressed :) I used to copy mine from the English textbooks, they always seemed to have a ton; like one for you being sick and one for your mom being sick etc. etc.</p> “Dude… I learnt writing like this”

You wrote your sickness letters from scratch? I’m very impressed :) I used to copy mine from the English textbooks, they always seemed to have a ton; like one for you being sick and one for your mom being sick etc. etc.

]]>
By: DesiDudeInGotham (formerly of Austin) http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74656 DesiDudeInGotham (formerly of Austin) Sat, 22 Jul 2006 03:48:14 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74656 <blockquote>1. Hilarious! 2. I miss my grandfathers.</blockquote> <p>My "sick from cough and cold" letters to my schoolteachers from mum and dad were of this nature.</p> <p>Dude... <b><i>I</i></b> learnt writing like this. From Messers Wren & Martin no less. I could Wren-&-Martinize a post about Kaavya V. Or Wren-&-Martinize Opal Mehta itself. "How Opal Mehta came to be Osculated, to be Rampant and to be Self-Realized"</p> 1. Hilarious! 2. I miss my grandfathers.

My “sick from cough and cold” letters to my schoolteachers from mum and dad were of this nature.

Dude… I learnt writing like this. From Messers Wren & Martin no less. I could Wren-&-Martinize a post about Kaavya V. Or Wren-&-Martinize Opal Mehta itself. “How Opal Mehta came to be Osculated, to be Rampant and to be Self-Realized”

]]>
By: Saurav http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74653 Saurav Sat, 22 Jul 2006 03:22:48 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74653 <blockquote>In re. your article on the 20th inst. I find it aggravating that you should not bear in mind the other type of Indian English, viz. the species that is afflicted by a epistolatory style that was more in vogue circa the 19th century. I expect comments of the above nature to be forthcoming, inasmuch as many among us know many others who continue to communicate in such outmoded fashion - esp. in their missives. Many of those were educated well in St.Xav, St. Ed, Fr. Wm. High and other such saintly institutions of grammatical edification that fortunately remained untainted by the presence of journals such as the ones that you make mention of. Thence, these students, armed with their superiour education have climbed to the very heights of the civil services, in the business professions and other positions of influence by dint of their dilligence and lucubration. One may venture, nay hope, that in the fullness of time, these able professional men of sound faculties will be able to expunge such publications from Society. Your most obediently, DDiG Esq. BS MS ABD</blockquote> <p>My two reactions:</p> <ol> <li>Hilarious!</li> <li>I miss my grandfathers.</li> </ol> In re. your article on the 20th inst. I find it aggravating that you should not bear in mind the other type of Indian English, viz. the species that is afflicted by a epistolatory style that was more in vogue circa the 19th century. I expect comments of the above nature to be forthcoming, inasmuch as many among us know many others who continue to communicate in such outmoded fashion – esp. in their missives. Many of those were educated well in St.Xav, St. Ed, Fr. Wm. High and other such saintly institutions of grammatical edification that fortunately remained untainted by the presence of journals such as the ones that you make mention of. Thence, these students, armed with their superiour education have climbed to the very heights of the civil services, in the business professions and other positions of influence by dint of their dilligence and lucubration. One may venture, nay hope, that in the fullness of time, these able professional men of sound faculties will be able to expunge such publications from Society. Your most obediently, DDiG Esq. BS MS ABD

My two reactions:

  1. Hilarious!
  2. I miss my grandfathers.
]]>
By: Neha http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/07/20/i_smell_a_revol/comment-page-2/#comment-74647 Neha Sat, 22 Jul 2006 02:01:19 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3602#comment-74647 <blockquote>No, I say the British are the only people pronouncing English properly. It's their language, they get final say over the proper pronunciation</blockquote> <p><b>sa</b>, British English is a rather broad umbrella. I mean, I can't understand a word of Welsh English. Hell, I don't know how many <i>English</i> people can understand Welsh. Yes, everything does seem to sound smarter in "BBC English" or "Queen's English" but it is so much more fun to converse with people who speak in a Cockney or Yorkshire dialect :-)</p> No, I say the British are the only people pronouncing English properly. It’s their language, they get final say over the proper pronunciation

sa, British English is a rather broad umbrella. I mean, I can’t understand a word of Welsh English. Hell, I don’t know how many English people can understand Welsh. Yes, everything does seem to sound smarter in “BBC English” or “Queen’s English” but it is so much more fun to converse with people who speak in a Cockney or Yorkshire dialect :-)

]]>