Comments on: Saturday55: “The Mercy Seat” Edition http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/ All that flavorful brownness in one savory packet Sat, 30 Nov 2013 11:11:28 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: A N N A http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59981 A N N A Thu, 04 May 2006 02:53:09 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59981 <blockquote>For the hundredth time why not just respond to the specific charge and defend yourself?</blockquote> <p>I'm in a generous mood, especially for someone with nothing better to do than cravenly insult someone on a BLOG while their friends watch.</p> <p>Here, enjoy three answers to your loaded question:</p> <p>1) I haven't done anything which I need to defend-- none of the phrases you gleefully cite are THAT redundant. Try Google define:, I did, b/c I take <i>constructive</i> criticism seriously. Once the definitions I read confirmed that you were being obnoxious, I saw no need to reply to you in a manner more mature than your own.</p> <p>2) You obviously don't <i>want</i> to discuss or debate anything with me, you just like to judge and heckle from an anonymous place-- no accountability is great, but the flip-side is no credibility. Why is it relevant to know you? Because if you aren't willing to put yourself behind your words, you don't really mean them and it's likely you're a troll.</p> <p>3) Your mind can't be changed, so why waste my time disabusing you of all the things which you've assumed, which aren't even accurate?</p> <p>There was no need to change your IP address. One of the many things you were inaccurate about was a proclivity to ban anyone who dislikes my writing; we ban based on clear violations of our comment policy. I'm not the Maharani of the Mutiny. The other bloggers I am lucky enough to write with aren't blinded by love and baseless devotion to me-- they do me no favors. If they ban you, it's because you really deserved it.</p> <p>Go ahead, continue in this unnecessary vein. If it makes you <i>that</i> happy you have far more serious problems than I ever will with my sucky writing.</p> <p>I'm going to the gym. I'll smell you later.</p> For the hundredth time why not just respond to the specific charge and defend yourself?

I’m in a generous mood, especially for someone with nothing better to do than cravenly insult someone on a BLOG while their friends watch.

Here, enjoy three answers to your loaded question:

1) I haven’t done anything which I need to defend– none of the phrases you gleefully cite are THAT redundant. Try Google define:, I did, b/c I take constructive criticism seriously. Once the definitions I read confirmed that you were being obnoxious, I saw no need to reply to you in a manner more mature than your own.

2) You obviously don’t want to discuss or debate anything with me, you just like to judge and heckle from an anonymous place– no accountability is great, but the flip-side is no credibility. Why is it relevant to know you? Because if you aren’t willing to put yourself behind your words, you don’t really mean them and it’s likely you’re a troll.

3) Your mind can’t be changed, so why waste my time disabusing you of all the things which you’ve assumed, which aren’t even accurate?

There was no need to change your IP address. One of the many things you were inaccurate about was a proclivity to ban anyone who dislikes my writing; we ban based on clear violations of our comment policy. I’m not the Maharani of the Mutiny. The other bloggers I am lucky enough to write with aren’t blinded by love and baseless devotion to me– they do me no favors. If they ban you, it’s because you really deserved it.

Go ahead, continue in this unnecessary vein. If it makes you that happy you have far more serious problems than I ever will with my sucky writing.

I’m going to the gym. I’ll smell you later.

]]>
By: ANNA's Logic Sucks http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59971 ANNA's Logic Sucks Thu, 04 May 2006 02:17:38 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59971 <p>"How prescient of you! '', my friends exclaimed upon reading your juvenile response. Friends, in whose presence, I had posted comments on your poor writing ( I had read a couple of earlier posts by you as well ) and whom I had forewarned about the overtly emotional but abysmally illogical rebuttals the post would beget. But I am no psychic. I had chanced upon a similar response by you and your ' brown ' minions to yet another person's criticism of your writing. If I am not wrong, not only did you guys ban that person but were bloodthirsty enough to ' out ' him. What's up with wanting to know your critics' identity? Why not just either disagree or concur with what they say? For God's sake this is a blog. It seems your idea of one-upping the debate is to start calling opponents names ( <b>shit-talking master</b> ) and giving them the finger (<b>literally</b>). Why does the critic have to be a better writer than you to justify the criticism? Even a high schooler could point out the four redundancies in the very small piece written by you, ironically, to solicit pieces of good writing! For the hundredth time why not just respond to the specific charge and defend yourself?</p> <p>The bigger point is the low literary/performance expectations that your ' brown peeps ' have of one of their own kind. Didn't I read somewhere you are part of some South Asian Creative Collective? Someone in an earlier post on this blog even nominated you for the accolade of being one of the most accomplished young South Asian women! Your most visible talent - <b>writing</b>, I hope was not the reason. I am guessing your inexplicable defense of that unapologetic cheat, Ms Vishwanathan, is in fact an unconscious admission of your own lousy writing. Just like those ambitious Indians ( one example - singer Shaheen Sheik discussed on this blog ) who figured early on they won't amount to much in mainstream West ( even though born and raised in the West ) and so relaunched their careers in the old country, you too as a budding writer ( I would assume you are ) should set your sights on the Indian market instead. Your incessant self segregating rants of brown this and brown that have already put you upto speed for the transformation.</p> <p>I have to run before your lackeys verbally lynch me.</p> “How prescient of you! ”, my friends exclaimed upon reading your juvenile response. Friends, in whose presence, I had posted comments on your poor writing ( I had read a couple of earlier posts by you as well ) and whom I had forewarned about the overtly emotional but abysmally illogical rebuttals the post would beget. But I am no psychic. I had chanced upon a similar response by you and your ‘ brown ‘ minions to yet another person’s criticism of your writing. If I am not wrong, not only did you guys ban that person but were bloodthirsty enough to ‘ out ‘ him. What’s up with wanting to know your critics’ identity? Why not just either disagree or concur with what they say? For God’s sake this is a blog. It seems your idea of one-upping the debate is to start calling opponents names ( shit-talking master ) and giving them the finger (literally). Why does the critic have to be a better writer than you to justify the criticism? Even a high schooler could point out the four redundancies in the very small piece written by you, ironically, to solicit pieces of good writing! For the hundredth time why not just respond to the specific charge and defend yourself?

The bigger point is the low literary/performance expectations that your ‘ brown peeps ‘ have of one of their own kind. Didn’t I read somewhere you are part of some South Asian Creative Collective? Someone in an earlier post on this blog even nominated you for the accolade of being one of the most accomplished young South Asian women! Your most visible talent – writing, I hope was not the reason. I am guessing your inexplicable defense of that unapologetic cheat, Ms Vishwanathan, is in fact an unconscious admission of your own lousy writing. Just like those ambitious Indians ( one example – singer Shaheen Sheik discussed on this blog ) who figured early on they won’t amount to much in mainstream West ( even though born and raised in the West ) and so relaunched their careers in the old country, you too as a budding writer ( I would assume you are ) should set your sights on the Indian market instead. Your incessant self segregating rants of brown this and brown that have already put you upto speed for the transformation.

I have to run before your lackeys verbally lynch me.

]]>
By: Meena http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59876 Meena Wed, 03 May 2006 22:57:19 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59876 <p>hehehe, right on anna :)</p> hehehe, right on anna :)

]]>
By: A N N A http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59866 A N N A Wed, 03 May 2006 21:50:57 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59866 <p>teach me, oh great and wise shit-talking master, so that i may know your superior ways.</p> <p>do you have a blog or something published which i can read, so that i can absorb (nay, internalize!) the work of a writer so confident, they feel they have the right to diss and dismiss? do you have a name i can respond to when i reply like this? no? then <a href="http://www.sepiamutiny.com/sepia/images/AnnaFlippingOffCamera.jpg">here is my response</a>.</p> teach me, oh great and wise shit-talking master, so that i may know your superior ways.

do you have a blog or something published which i can read, so that i can absorb (nay, internalize!) the work of a writer so confident, they feel they have the right to diss and dismiss? do you have a name i can respond to when i reply like this? no? then here is my response.

]]>
By: ANNA's Writing Sucks http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59847 ANNA's Writing Sucks Wed, 03 May 2006 20:35:09 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59847 <p>Very new to this blog.I understand ANNA is a star blogger here. Really? I read somewhere she took writing classes. Isn't the first thing taught there is to avoid redundancy? <i> <i>ignorant racism</i> pristine, sacred creation</i> <i>shocked us in to a deep dismay</i> <i>concentrated, concise story </i></p> Very new to this blog.I understand ANNA is a star blogger here. Really? I read somewhere she took writing classes. Isn’t the first thing taught there is to avoid redundancy? ignorant racism pristine, sacred creation shocked us in to a deep dismay concentrated, concise story

]]>
By: pk http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59710 pk Wed, 03 May 2006 08:17:22 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59710 <p>this is slightly more than 55, but i'm too lazy to shorten it.</p> <p>Dedicated to the Kaavya in Us All</p> <p>She wanted to rip the stage with appropriate “Fuck Whitey” and “I AinÂ’t No Curry Mango Girl” sprinkled into her delivery. She knew that type of roaring Spoken Word would awaken the crowd. She gripped the mic, ready to throw down.</p> <p>But that wasnÂ’t her. Her dice had landed on the good girl shit.</p> <p>She pulled out the poems, and settled for reading what she had written.</p> this is slightly more than 55, but i’m too lazy to shorten it.

Dedicated to the Kaavya in Us All

She wanted to rip the stage with appropriate “Fuck Whitey” and “I Ain’t No Curry Mango Girl” sprinkled into her delivery. She knew that type of roaring Spoken Word would awaken the crowd. She gripped the mic, ready to throw down.

But that wasnÂ’t her. Her dice had landed on the good girl shit.

She pulled out the poems, and settled for reading what she had written.

]]>
By: A N N A http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59562 A N N A Tue, 02 May 2006 21:02:45 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59562 <p>Jai, I totally think you should keep the new handle. Suits you. ;)</p> Jai, I totally think you should keep the new handle. Suits you. ;)

]]>
By: thekingsingh http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59549 thekingsingh Tue, 02 May 2006 20:22:17 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59549 <p><i>Sorry, this is a bit late... :)</i></p> <p>To great musical crescendo, the movie reached its climactic scene, as the protagonist was hoisted upright by soldiers, crucified.</p> <p>“Daddy?”</p> <p>Her father, fixated to the TV, snapped himself out of his gaze, realizing that his daughter was also watching.</p> <p>“Yes?” he replied, with trepidation.</p> <p>“Daddy”, she said pointing to the TV, “that man, heÂ’th thtuck!”</p> Sorry, this is a bit late… :)

To great musical crescendo, the movie reached its climactic scene, as the protagonist was hoisted upright by soldiers, crucified.

“Daddy?”

Her father, fixated to the TV, snapped himself out of his gaze, realizing that his daughter was also watching.

“Yes?” he replied, with trepidation.

“Daddy”, she said pointing to the TV, “that man, he’th thtuck!”

]]>
By: Jai aka LLCoolJai http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59492 Jai aka LLCoolJai Tue, 02 May 2006 18:51:11 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59492 <p>Aw, that's a nice thing to say, Anna. Hopefully any swooning that goes on will be due to my understated charm and quietly debonair manner, and not because I overdid it with the aftershave again ;)</p> Aw, that’s a nice thing to say, Anna. Hopefully any swooning that goes on will be due to my understated charm and quietly debonair manner, and not because I overdid it with the aftershave again ;)

]]>
By: A N N A http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/04/29/saturday55_the_2/comment-page-1/#comment-59447 A N N A Tue, 02 May 2006 17:26:34 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=3309#comment-59447 <p>Jai, stock up on smelling salts. If I ever met you, I think I would swoooooon.</p> Jai, stock up on smelling salts. If I ever met you, I think I would swoooooon.

]]>