Comments on: Math nerds needed. ASAP. http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/ All that flavorful brownness in one savory packet Sat, 30 Nov 2013 11:11:28 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: jak http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-2/#comment-44379 jak Thu, 02 Feb 2006 10:01:32 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44379 <p>hello gang, responding to the requests of khatri and tandon :- a looong story short: I'm a first gen (meaning parents born in india, while little ol' me was born here). And guess what? - undergrad in engineering (which kind you ask? Electrical. Yup, the WORST kind. Fields and Waves and Everything. Two internships (NEC and Raytheon)). - worked for less than 3 years as an engineer (Data General - anyone remember Data General?) - After my 3 year stint, I turned tail and fled, jumped ship, bailed out, geronimooooo... - what did I do? Moved into mom's basement... and got a second undergrad degree in History (in just 4 semesters, by the way; lots of credits xferred, luckily) (yup, history. 'world history'). Yes, mom had a heart attack and dad thought I had lost my mind. ;) Luckily I had a sister who did nearly the same thing (Mechanical engineering, worked 4 years, bailed, masters in journalism, now is very, very happy, and recently won an AP award actually). - After my second bachelors, applied to grad school for south asian history. Amazingly, got into my first and second choices (I only applied to three schools). Now I'm very, very happily finishing up phd.</p> <p>So that said, I can totally relate to techies and capitalists. ;) They're like old family to me. I'm also, tho, happy to do something completely different. Always been more interested in politics and history, in the end.</p> <p>-incidentally, if the whole career change hadn't worked out, my backup plan? Why, Patent Law, of course! ;D Luckily, I didnt have to open that parachute.</p> <p>so there's one for your data collection... ;)</p> hello gang, responding to the requests of khatri and tandon :- a looong story short: I’m a first gen (meaning parents born in india, while little ol’ me was born here). And guess what? - undergrad in engineering (which kind you ask? Electrical. Yup, the WORST kind. Fields and Waves and Everything. Two internships (NEC and Raytheon)). - worked for less than 3 years as an engineer (Data General – anyone remember Data General?) – After my 3 year stint, I turned tail and fled, jumped ship, bailed out, geronimooooo… - what did I do? Moved into mom’s basement… and got a second undergrad degree in History (in just 4 semesters, by the way; lots of credits xferred, luckily) (yup, history. ‘world history’). Yes, mom had a heart attack and dad thought I had lost my mind. ;) Luckily I had a sister who did nearly the same thing (Mechanical engineering, worked 4 years, bailed, masters in journalism, now is very, very happy, and recently won an AP award actually). - After my second bachelors, applied to grad school for south asian history. Amazingly, got into my first and second choices (I only applied to three schools). Now I’m very, very happily finishing up phd.

So that said, I can totally relate to techies and capitalists. ;) They’re like old family to me. I’m also, tho, happy to do something completely different. Always been more interested in politics and history, in the end.

-incidentally, if the whole career change hadn’t worked out, my backup plan? Why, Patent Law, of course! ;D Luckily, I didnt have to open that parachute.

so there’s one for your data collection… ;)

]]>
By: Guru Gulab Khatri http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44356 Guru Gulab Khatri Thu, 02 Feb 2006 05:47:12 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44356 <blockquote>Can we please do this exercise, if you allow: 1) If you are a 2nd/ 1.5 genner. 2) Have a training in science and technology field. Leave a comment.</blockquote> <p>comment</p> Can we please do this exercise, if you allow: 1) If you are a 2nd/ 1.5 genner. 2) Have a training in science and technology field. Leave a comment.

comment

]]>
By: Salil Maniktahla http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44306 Salil Maniktahla Wed, 01 Feb 2006 23:05:28 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44306 <p>Curious: no one discussed the silliness:</p> <blockquote>After the moon mission, India wants to reach out to Mars and the government is keen to jump onto a possible global bandwagon for this potentially exciting planetary exploration.</blockquote> <p>Um. Ok. Does anyone want to discuss the idea that manned space exploration has become nothing more than a series of prideful flag-plantings, with almost no emphasis on meaningful exploration, sustainability, or cost-effectiveness? I can easily see India's space program following America's after reading quotes like that.</p> Curious: no one discussed the silliness:

After the moon mission, India wants to reach out to Mars and the government is keen to jump onto a possible global bandwagon for this potentially exciting planetary exploration.

Um. Ok. Does anyone want to discuss the idea that manned space exploration has become nothing more than a series of prideful flag-plantings, with almost no emphasis on meaningful exploration, sustainability, or cost-effectiveness? I can easily see India’s space program following America’s after reading quotes like that.

]]>
By: DesiDancer http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44302 DesiDancer Wed, 01 Feb 2006 22:49:56 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44302 <p>thanks V and Vij</p> thanks V and Vij

]]>
By: vinod-at-large http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44297 vinod-at-large Wed, 01 Feb 2006 22:42:30 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44297 <p>desidancer - it's age independent. I blogged a bit about it <a href="http://www.vinod.com/blog/News/HardAmericaSoftAmerica.html">here</a>...</p> desidancer – it’s age independent. I blogged a bit about it here

]]>
By: Manish Vij http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44295 Manish Vij Wed, 01 Feb 2006 22:39:31 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44295 <p>From the reviews on Amazon, it's age-independent. The book blames liberal universities and lauds the conservative business world.</p> From the reviews on Amazon, it’s age-independent. The book blames liberal universities and lauds the conservative business world.

]]>
By: DesiDancer http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44288 DesiDancer Wed, 01 Feb 2006 21:56:57 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44288 <p>vinod (at large, or elsewhere), does Hard America, Soft America base its concept on the difference between Gen X and Gen Y, or on the difference between any 18-20 year olds and any 30 year olds, regardless of the generation?</p> vinod (at large, or elsewhere), does Hard America, Soft America base its concept on the difference between Gen X and Gen Y, or on the difference between any 18-20 year olds and any 30 year olds, regardless of the generation?

]]>
By: Manish Vij http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44277 Manish Vij Wed, 01 Feb 2006 20:57:10 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44277 <blockquote>America's 20 yr olds are idiots, 30 yr olds brilliant</blockquote> <p>And you're in the latter camp :)</p> America’s 20 yr olds are idiots, 30 yr olds brilliant

And you’re in the latter camp :)

]]>
By: Ennis http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44276 Ennis Wed, 01 Feb 2006 20:54:08 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44276 <p>Sorry, haven't been following this thread. I was a member of Tau Beta Pi, which I guess should qualify me as well.</p> Sorry, haven’t been following this thread. I was a member of Tau Beta Pi, which I guess should qualify me as well.

]]>
By: vinod-at-large http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2006/01/31/math_nerds_need/comment-page-1/#comment-44274 vinod-at-large Wed, 01 Feb 2006 20:49:26 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2941#comment-44274 <blockquote>But what about the future? The next 20-30 years? Can we (Americans) compete? ... Most of the high school kids around here have no clue that their financial future is in such peril. They DON'T want to do math/science, many don't even want to go to college...it is all about partying all the time, getting drunk, making some quick cash to burn it all over the weekend.</blockquote> <p>I'm on the fence.</p> <p>I see the seeds of greatness and the seeds of failure and on net, think things will generally be ok. In part, I'm a big believer in the <a href="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1400053242/102-6357476-3663367?v=glance&n=283155">Hard America, Soft America</a> argument (roughly - America's 20 yr olds are idiots, 30 yr olds brilliant).</p> <p>I think Sci / Engineering is critical, but i don't think we're at a crisis point w.r.t. "underinvestment" in this space. And I certainly don't see the global economy in quite the same competitive, zero-sum game that the space race was. From a prima facie, Econ 101 standpoint, if India + China have 10x the engineers of the US in the near future, that <em>INCREASES</em> our standard of living.</p> <p>I also agree that Math / Sci / Eng education can / should be overhauled - it's no accident that so many of the best techie's I've come across over the years are / were jaded by school and the tech ed process. In >10 yrs in the tech biz (MSFT, silicon valley, startups, big co's, etc.) I can't tell you how many times I've seen the proverbial USC slacker outperform the CalTech 4.0 ..... the best, most passionate programmers are often the late night hackers rather than the straight-A students.</p> <p>and the phenomena of the academic underachiever but tech/biz overachiever is a very American one (my USC techie above, Bram Cohen, Marc Andreeson, many other lesser known silicon valley examples, etc.).</p> <p>And it's hard to think of a better of example of how f*cked up the education process has become.</p> <blockquote>where did you get the number regarding the "wizards" making 7 figures ? Without stock options that figure is just too high. Even after allowing for stock options</blockquote> <p>I'm including all sources of comp - salary + stock options + stock grants. Top salaries within (pure) tech top out in the low 100's of K. It's stock that puts you over. And if you avg over several years, the top guys at these firms truly are making 7 figures. Not always, but often.</p> <blockquote>Put another way, who'd classify as a "wizard" ? At MSFT: only Nathan Myrvhold? or all of MSFT research ? Or the product manager for MS Excel ? Or all product managers ?</blockquote> <p>the wizards I'm thinking of are the top 2-3 engineers within a 100 person dev team @ MSFT. Within Google, b/c of recent, crazy stock price appreciation, it's likely that the top 3-4 engineers with a <em>10 person</em> team are millionaires. At an IBM, it's probably only the top 2-3 within 1000 who are in the deep 100's of K.</p> But what about the future? The next 20-30 years? Can we (Americans) compete? … Most of the high school kids around here have no clue that their financial future is in such peril. They DON’T want to do math/science, many don’t even want to go to college…it is all about partying all the time, getting drunk, making some quick cash to burn it all over the weekend.

I’m on the fence.

I see the seeds of greatness and the seeds of failure and on net, think things will generally be ok. In part, I’m a big believer in the Hard America, Soft America argument (roughly – America’s 20 yr olds are idiots, 30 yr olds brilliant).

I think Sci / Engineering is critical, but i don’t think we’re at a crisis point w.r.t. “underinvestment” in this space. And I certainly don’t see the global economy in quite the same competitive, zero-sum game that the space race was. From a prima facie, Econ 101 standpoint, if India + China have 10x the engineers of the US in the near future, that INCREASES our standard of living.

I also agree that Math / Sci / Eng education can / should be overhauled – it’s no accident that so many of the best techie’s I’ve come across over the years are / were jaded by school and the tech ed process. In >10 yrs in the tech biz (MSFT, silicon valley, startups, big co’s, etc.) I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen the proverbial USC slacker outperform the CalTech 4.0 ….. the best, most passionate programmers are often the late night hackers rather than the straight-A students.

and the phenomena of the academic underachiever but tech/biz overachiever is a very American one (my USC techie above, Bram Cohen, Marc Andreeson, many other lesser known silicon valley examples, etc.).

And it’s hard to think of a better of example of how f*cked up the education process has become.

where did you get the number regarding the “wizards” making 7 figures ? Without stock options that figure is just too high. Even after allowing for stock options

I’m including all sources of comp – salary + stock options + stock grants. Top salaries within (pure) tech top out in the low 100′s of K. It’s stock that puts you over. And if you avg over several years, the top guys at these firms truly are making 7 figures. Not always, but often.

Put another way, who’d classify as a “wizard” ? At MSFT: only Nathan Myrvhold? or all of MSFT research ? Or the product manager for MS Excel ? Or all product managers ?

the wizards I’m thinking of are the top 2-3 engineers within a 100 person dev team @ MSFT. Within Google, b/c of recent, crazy stock price appreciation, it’s likely that the top 3-4 engineers with a 10 person team are millionaires. At an IBM, it’s probably only the top 2-3 within 1000 who are in the deep 100′s of K.

]]>