Comments on: They’re Lucky Champawat isn’t Alive http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/ All that flavorful brownness in one savory packet Sat, 30 Nov 2013 11:11:28 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Lavania http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-276322 Lavania Tue, 20 Jul 2010 04:54:45 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-276322 <p>I am researching project tiger as part of my thesis and as a distraction I got into collecting a fair bit of info on Corbett/ I do have to say that Corbetts legacy is complex and nuanced and yet all narratives are very simple.</p> I am researching project tiger as part of my thesis and as a distraction I got into collecting a fair bit of info on Corbett/ I do have to say that Corbetts legacy is complex and nuanced and yet all narratives are very simple.

]]>
By: Praveen http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-273513 Praveen Thu, 10 Jun 2010 05:52:02 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-273513 <p>that was brilliant.i mean i champwat was alive,kind of hitch to some.</p> that was brilliant.i mean i champwat was alive,kind of hitch to some.

]]>
By: Desi Ganwar http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-165523 Desi Ganwar Thu, 13 Sep 2007 01:41:18 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-165523 <p>I have been researching corbett and I don't find him worthy of adoration, but find him a Charlton. Well and Indians probably the rest of the world too indulges in that kind of mental masturbation.</p> <p>His exploits were embellished. I have read nearly all his works and I just dont know where to begin with the guy. He claims an exaggerated number of kills to individual tiger. Then he also photographs himself with them. They are in all cases healthy large specimen. The kind hunters would kill for a trophy. How the fuck did man eating tigers have near perfect coat, a large muscular body, and a jaw which shows full set of tooth. And forget the tone of the rest of the writing forget the fact that the indian tribals had been living in the vicinity of the jungle for ages and ooh the poor villagers, tribals, weaklings cant take care of missing person or a man kill or let alone even investigate it themselves, well in that case of course I a white knight was there to protect them. I urge others to look at his writings and photographs and oh yes actual tigers rather than serenading a concocted legacy.</p> I have been researching corbett and I don’t find him worthy of adoration, but find him a Charlton. Well and Indians probably the rest of the world too indulges in that kind of mental masturbation.

His exploits were embellished. I have read nearly all his works and I just dont know where to begin with the guy. He claims an exaggerated number of kills to individual tiger. Then he also photographs himself with them. They are in all cases healthy large specimen. The kind hunters would kill for a trophy. How the fuck did man eating tigers have near perfect coat, a large muscular body, and a jaw which shows full set of tooth. And forget the tone of the rest of the writing forget the fact that the indian tribals had been living in the vicinity of the jungle for ages and ooh the poor villagers, tribals, weaklings cant take care of missing person or a man kill or let alone even investigate it themselves, well in that case of course I a white knight was there to protect them. I urge others to look at his writings and photographs and oh yes actual tigers rather than serenading a concocted legacy.

]]>
By: Hasnain Ibrahim http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-149219 Hasnain Ibrahim Thu, 12 Jul 2007 04:59:46 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-149219 <p>Hey Guru: How can you make such a comment about Jim Corbett without even knowing the slightest about this great man ?. Yes, in his youger years he may have been trigger happy, but he soon realized his worng ways and devoted his entire life and savings to help save the environment and at the end not only creating the first national park of India but taking a huge step towards saving the tiger (which in turn helped save many other species which were close to extinction). He is still fondly remembered even today by the common people (how many other people really are ?.) The people Corbett called lovingly "the poor of India").</p> Hey Guru: How can you make such a comment about Jim Corbett without even knowing the slightest about this great man ?. Yes, in his youger years he may have been trigger happy, but he soon realized his worng ways and devoted his entire life and savings to help save the environment and at the end not only creating the first national park of India but taking a huge step towards saving the tiger (which in turn helped save many other species which were close to extinction). He is still fondly remembered even today by the common people (how many other people really are ?.) The people Corbett called lovingly “the poor of India”).

]]>
By: Serengetiman http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-139548 Serengetiman Sun, 27 May 2007 04:59:23 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-139548 <p>"Jim Corbett was a blatant self promotion con astist type that the brits encouraged in india. Maneaters of kumaon is nothing but self promotion by a vain dickhead."</p> <p>Mr Guru you really don´t know what you are talking about research a bit before you open your dirty mouth. It is a shame to hear somebody refering to Corbett in such a disrespectfull way. Corbett was a great storyteller, a sportsman with a great heart, always ready to help the Kumaon folks. He is a legend in the Kumaon hills and reading his book "Maneaters of Kumaon" when I was a young was in fact a delicious nectar to my soul. I am a Corbett lover and I have visited his grave in Nyeri, Kenya. It is my dream to visit Corbett homeland in India.Corbett forever!!!</p> “Jim Corbett was a blatant self promotion con astist type that the brits encouraged in india. Maneaters of kumaon is nothing but self promotion by a vain dickhead.”

Mr Guru you really don´t know what you are talking about research a bit before you open your dirty mouth. It is a shame to hear somebody refering to Corbett in such a disrespectfull way. Corbett was a great storyteller, a sportsman with a great heart, always ready to help the Kumaon folks. He is a legend in the Kumaon hills and reading his book “Maneaters of Kumaon” when I was a young was in fact a delicious nectar to my soul. I am a Corbett lover and I have visited his grave in Nyeri, Kenya. It is my dream to visit Corbett homeland in India.Corbett forever!!!

]]>
By: Mr Kevin Smith http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-81340 Mr Kevin Smith Wed, 23 Aug 2006 18:48:21 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-81340 <p>This book I found inspirational to such an extent that I travelled twice to Kaladunghi in UA, and stayed in close proximity to Corbetts winter home.</p> <p>The terrain though which Corbett operated is a vast area of mountain forest, still very rugged and without expansive acces.</p> <p>I have walked in the jungle and along riverbeds in an area not more than 1 mile from his home, where the pugmarks of Tiger are still to be found close to habitation and recent encounters recounted.</p> <p>While walking alone through grasses 18" high, or across river valleys still frequented by Tigers, the sense of being severely second best is very real.</p> <p>To endure the rigourous privations that the climate, geography and quarry demanded is a testiment to a real man.</p> This book I found inspirational to such an extent that I travelled twice to Kaladunghi in UA, and stayed in close proximity to Corbetts winter home.

The terrain though which Corbett operated is a vast area of mountain forest, still very rugged and without expansive acces.

I have walked in the jungle and along riverbeds in an area not more than 1 mile from his home, where the pugmarks of Tiger are still to be found close to habitation and recent encounters recounted.

While walking alone through grasses 18″ high, or across river valleys still frequented by Tigers, the sense of being severely second best is very real.

To endure the rigourous privations that the climate, geography and quarry demanded is a testiment to a real man.

]]>
By: Sumanth http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-77664 Sumanth Tue, 08 Aug 2006 11:59:19 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-77664 <p>@guru gulab khatri: What u say may well be true about the number of ppl killed by tigers today. But you bring a shallow argument to the table.</p> <p>Firstly-You do realise that for tigers to kill people, first there have to be tigers.</p> <p>Secindly-The tiger population in the 1920s was estimated to be about 40,000. Today it hovers around 4000 (if we are optimistic). The Human population in the 1920s in the kumaon region was 45,000 and today is around 35.64 lacs (census taken in 2001). You do the math.</p> <p>Though one must read Corbetts stories with a pinch of salt, on the whole i think they are brilliant, written and narrated extremely well and in the end he always has promoted the need for survival of the tiger, which is what makes him a great man. reducing this man to what you call "a vain dickhead" is a shameless act of ignorance.</p> @guru gulab khatri: What u say may well be true about the number of ppl killed by tigers today. But you bring a shallow argument to the table.

Firstly-You do realise that for tigers to kill people, first there have to be tigers.

Secindly-The tiger population in the 1920s was estimated to be about 40,000. Today it hovers around 4000 (if we are optimistic). The Human population in the 1920s in the kumaon region was 45,000 and today is around 35.64 lacs (census taken in 2001). You do the math.

Though one must read Corbetts stories with a pinch of salt, on the whole i think they are brilliant, written and narrated extremely well and in the end he always has promoted the need for survival of the tiger, which is what makes him a great man. reducing this man to what you call “a vain dickhead” is a shameless act of ignorance.

]]>
By: EW http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-36772 EW Sat, 03 Dec 2005 23:14:46 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-36772 <p>Guru Gulab Khatri You need to know what you are talking about befor you speek. Yes Jim Corbett killed many tigers but he was also Conservationist spending his life not only proteing villagers from man-eating tigers, but also traveling to many regions puting conservation of animals in the public eye. He is also responsible for the first national park in India. So please do your research befor giving an opinion.</p> Guru Gulab Khatri You need to know what you are talking about befor you speek. Yes Jim Corbett killed many tigers but he was also Conservationist spending his life not only proteing villagers from man-eating tigers, but also traveling to many regions puting conservation of animals in the public eye. He is also responsible for the first national park in India. So please do your research befor giving an opinion.

]]>
By: Michael H. http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-35719 Michael H. Wed, 23 Nov 2005 16:57:03 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-35719 <p>I read a not particularly interesting and not entirely flattering biography of Jim Corbett (by Martin Booth - but I don't recommend). It said that Corbett might have embellished his stories a bit but he really did kill these man-eating tigers and leopards.</p> <p>The reason that the number of man-eating incidents was so high in the first part of the 20th century was that humans were encroaching onto the tigers' territory. Today, there is no jungle in India apart from the few parks. What few tigers remain live in these parks and have little contact with humans.</p> I read a not particularly interesting and not entirely flattering biography of Jim Corbett (by Martin Booth – but I don’t recommend). It said that Corbett might have embellished his stories a bit but he really did kill these man-eating tigers and leopards.

The reason that the number of man-eating incidents was so high in the first part of the 20th century was that humans were encroaching onto the tigers’ territory. Today, there is no jungle in India apart from the few parks. What few tigers remain live in these parks and have little contact with humans.

]]>
By: Guru Gulab Khatri http://sepiamutiny.com/blog/2005/11/22/theyre_lucky_ch_1/comment-page-1/#comment-35652 Guru Gulab Khatri Wed, 23 Nov 2005 06:02:50 +0000 http://sepiamutiny.com?p=2559#comment-35652 <blockquote> I think that your comment is unwarranted. He hunted tigers at a time when it was not an issue of an endangered species. How was he a con artist. I have nothing for or against Jim Corbett, but am surprised at your outburst, without any signs of instigation. And the book you mention is a good read.</blockquote> <p>The book was required reading when i was growing up in india. I re read it when i traveled kumaon garwhal in 2002 Adding the numbers of people corbett claims that the beasts had killed its 1200+. Even today when there's a lot more human encroachment in number of incidents where tigers kill human are less than 12/yr.</p> I think that your comment is unwarranted. He hunted tigers at a time when it was not an issue of an endangered species. How was he a con artist. I have nothing for or against Jim Corbett, but am surprised at your outburst, without any signs of instigation. And the book you mention is a good read.

The book was required reading when i was growing up in india. I re read it when i traveled kumaon garwhal in 2002 Adding the numbers of people corbett claims that the beasts had killed its 1200+. Even today when there’s a lot more human encroachment in number of incidents where tigers kill human are less than 12/yr.

]]>